Published October 26, 2026

Touring Castlerock Homes? What Idaho Falls & Rexburg Buyers Should Know

Author Avatar

Written by Jacob Marcovitz

Craftsman-style new home with stone-wrapped porch columns and a fresh green lawn in an Eastern Idaho subdivision, with snowcapped mountains in the distance

Short answer: Castlerock Homes is a local Idaho Falls builder founded by Josh Higley, who Castlerock's website describes as a third-generation builder, and it has built in Southeast Idaho since 2013. Right now it builds in four subdivisions: Sand Creek Estates, Southpoint and Comore Loma in Idaho Falls, and Stonebridge in Rexburg. On October 26, 2026, its six priced homes on the MLS ran from $649,000 in Stonebridge to $819,000 in Sand Creek Estates.

The key thing to know before you tour: since November 2025, Castlerock's listed price is a base price, and options like air conditioning, landscaping and fencing are added on top. Ask for the total price with the options you want, in writing.

I'm Jacob Marcovitz, a REALTOR® with Keller Williams Realty East Idaho in Idaho Falls. I'm not employed by Castlerock Homes or any builder. This is what I go over with buyers before they visit a Castlerock home. For a shorter overview, see my Castlerock Homes page, and for every local builder, my new construction page.

Who is Castlerock Homes?

Here's how Castlerock describes itself on its website:

  • Founded: serving Southeast Idaho since 2013
  • Founder: Josh Higley, described as a third-generation builder with a lifetime of experience in construction and real estate
  • What it builds: "hundreds of custom and track homes," from starter homes to custom homes
  • Office: 1730 Woodruff Park Cir, Idaho Falls, per its Contact page

The "third-generation" part is Castlerock's own description; I didn't find an outside source that confirms or contradicts it. Not many sites cover Castlerock at all. When I searched in October 2026, I mostly found its own site and review directories, which is part of why I wrote this guide.

Castlerock is a mix of production and custom. It builds inventory homes from its own plans in its own subdivisions, and it will build custom. If you're not sure which route fits you, my production vs custom builder guide walks through the trade-offs.

Where does Castlerock build around Idaho Falls and Rexburg?

Castlerock's All Inventory page lists homes in four subdivisions. Here's what each one showed on October 26, 2026:

Sand Creek Estates (Idaho Falls)

  • What's listed: four homes: 1684 and 1662 Sandbar St, 5377 Boardwalk Rd and 5439 Rip Tide Rd
  • Size: 3,570 to 4,309 total sq ft, 5 to 7 bedrooms, on lots of about a quarter to 0.3 acre
  • Schools on the MLS listings: Sunnyside Elementary, Taylor View Junior High and Idaho Falls High (District 91)
  • HOA: $360 a year on the 1662 Sandbar MLS listing
  • Good to know: Castlerock posts the plat map and CC&Rs on its Sand Creek Estates page. Copper Creek Homes also builds in Sand Creek Estates, so you can compare two builders on the same streets.

Southpoint (Idaho Falls)

  • What's listed: 5942 Lemhi St, a 5-bed, 3-bath Spec 5 plan with 3,908 total sq ft on about 0.3 acre
  • Schools on the MLS listing: Sunnyside Elementary, Taylor View Junior High and Idaho Falls High (District 91)
  • HOA: the MLS shows a $405 HOA fee without saying how often it's billed, so ask
  • More on the area: my Southpoint neighborhood page

Comore Loma (Idaho Falls)

  • What's listed: 6916 S Packbridge Ln (a daylight walkout plan, 4,342 total sq ft) and 6754 S Tumble Creek Ln (Conwy XL plan, 4,210 total sq ft, with a 1,494 sq ft oversized garage)
  • Stage: Castlerock's September 20, 2026 photos showed a lot at Packbridge and framing at Tumble Creek
  • Price: I didn't find either home on the MLS on October 26, 2026, so ask Castlerock

Stonebridge (Rexburg)

  • What's listed: 566 and 522 Stonebridge St, 494 Tanglewood Dr (which Castlerock calls river-front) and a lot at Lot 13 Block 3
  • Size: 3,614 to 3,908 total sq ft, 5 or 6 bedrooms, on quarter-acre lots
  • Schools on the MLS listings: Adams Elementary, Madison Junior High and Madison High (Madison District 321)
  • HOA: the 566 Stonebridge listing shows no HOA; confirm for your lot
  • Good to know: Fall Creek Homes also builds in Stonebridge; see my Fall Creek guide

Always confirm the school for the exact address with the district. My school districts guide covers the Idaho Falls-area districts. If you're still choosing a side of town, start with my Idaho Falls neighborhood guide.

How much does a Castlerock home cost in 2026?

Castlerock's website doesn't show prices. These are the asking prices on Castlerock's six homes for sale on the Snake River MLS, checked October 26, 2026:

  • 566 Stonebridge St, Rexburg: $649,000. 6 bed, 3 bath, 3,614 total sq ft.
  • 522 Stonebridge St, Rexburg: $665,000. 6 bed, 3 bath, 3,735 total sq ft. The MLS remarks say it will be finished by November 18, 2026.
  • 5439 Rip Tide Rd, Sand Creek Estates (Idaho Falls): $670,000. 5 bed, 3.5 bath, 3,570 total sq ft.
  • 5942 Lemhi St, Southpoint (Idaho Falls): $700,000. 5 bed, 3 bath, 3,908 total sq ft.
  • 1684 Sandbar St, Sand Creek Estates (Idaho Falls): $780,000. 5 bed, 3 bath, 4,120 total sq ft.
  • 1662 Sandbar St, Sand Creek Estates (Idaho Falls): $819,000. 7 bed, 3 bath, 4,309 total sq ft.
  • No price found: 5377 Boardwalk Rd, 494 Tanglewood Dr and both Comore Loma homes weren't on the MLS. Call Castlerock.

Some quick math from those numbers: these homes list for about $178 to $190 per total square foot. About half of that total is a finished basement in every one of these homes. For example, 1662 Sandbar has 2,149 sq ft on the main floor and 2,160 below. If you're comparing against a builder that lists main-floor or above-grade space, compare the same way.

Prices have moved. Per the MLS price history, 1662 Sandbar was listed at $860,000 in May 2026 and had three price cuts between September 21 and October 19, and 522 Stonebridge went from $690,000 to $665,000. That doesn't promise more room to negotiate, but it's worth knowing before you make an offer. To see how a payment fits your budget, read my Idaho Falls cost of living guide and property taxes and HOAs explained.

How does Castlerock's base price and options pricing work?

This is the part that's different from most builders I cover. A note on Castlerock's website says that since November 2025:

  • The listed price is the base cost of the home only.
  • Options are added on top. Castlerock's examples are air conditioning, landscaping, fencing, an RV pad, upgraded appliances, extra lighting, extra gutters and downspouts, and any buyer closing costs you ask the seller to cover.
  • The goal, per Castlerock, is a competitive base price without surprise costs during construction or at closing.

What that means for you: two homes with the same asking price can end up far apart once you add what you want. Some MLS listings already show features like central air, and 1662 Sandbar's listing says it comes with full landscaping, while 5942 Lemhi's listing shows no landscaping. Before you compare Castlerock to Rockwell, Kartchner or Copper Creek, ask for a written list of what's already in the home and the total price with your options.

What comes standard in Castlerock's Signature and Luxury Series?

Castlerock builds from two plan collections, and each plan can be modified, per its Plans page, which also has 3D virtual tours.

Signature Series

  • Plans: Spec 1 through Spec 6, from 2,826 to 3,524 sq ft on the Signature Series page
  • Kitchen: granite or quartz counters, tile backsplash, Frigidaire stainless appliance package, knotty alder cabinets
  • Finishes: LV flooring in main-floor common areas, tile bathroom floors, 95% efficient furnace, Low-E windows, Cat 6 wiring to bedrooms, family room and kitchen
  • Exterior: brick or rock wainscot with vinyl siding above, architectural shingles with a 30-year warranty, rain gutters, sprinkler loop

Luxury Series

  • Plans: named plans including the Bedford, Edinburgh, Warwick, Somerset and Conwy XL (3,876 sq ft) on the Luxury Series page
  • Kitchen upgrades: KitchenAid stainless appliance package, pot filler, cabinets up to the ceiling with glass uppers, soft-close drawers, custom range hood
  • Other upgrades: stucco or SmartSide above the brick or rock, tile to the ceiling in showers, a 6-foot soaker tub in the primary bath (plan specific), and pre-wiring for home automation and security

Listings and features can differ from the website, so get the features list for your exact home in writing.

What's Castlerock's warranty?

Castlerock's Warranty page describes a limited one-year new home warranty:

  • Length: one year from closing. After that, you'd go to the product manufacturer.
  • How to file: written claims only, through an online form, with a detailed description and photos
  • Timing: Castlerock suggests waiting 60 days after closing before reporting non-emergency items, and says it usually replies by the end of the next business day
  • Maintenance matters: it says damage from poor drainage, gutters or misaimed sprinklers may not be covered

Ask whether the home also carries a third-party structural warranty, and get the full warranty agreement before you sign. Some builders I cover offer longer structural coverage, so it's a fair question when you compare.

Do I need my own Realtor to buy a Castlerock home?

You don't have to, but I recommend it. One thing to know up front: Castlerock's homes are listed on the MLS by Josh Higley through Keller Williams Realty East Idaho, which is also my brokerage. I don't work for Castlerock. If you want to buy one of its listed homes with me, I'll go over the agency disclosure with you in writing before you write an offer, so you know exactly who represents whom. On a Castlerock purchase, I:

  • Check the current MLS price, status and price history
  • Get the base price, every option you want and the total into the written contract
  • Compare finished square feet, and main floor vs basement, across builders
  • Set up an independent inspection and walk the final punch list with you
  • Track deadlines, deposits and the completion date (I'm not an attorney, and I'll point you to one for legal questions)

That doesn't mean you're stuck paying it. With more homes on the market and buyers gaining leverage, Jacob can negotiate to have his compensation covered by the seller as part of your offer, and he'll make sure you aren't overpaying for the home.

Text me at 208-821-6217 before your first visit. You can read more about me here. If you're relocating for Idaho National Laboratory, start with my INL relocation guide. Buying from out of state? My out-of-state relocator guide covers buying from a distance.

What should I ask on a Castlerock tour?

  • What's the base price, which options are already in this home, and what's the total with the options I want?
  • Is A/C installed? Is landscaping or fencing included?
  • How much of the square footage is on the main floor, and how much is basement?
  • What's the estimated completion date, and what happens if it slips?
  • Has the price changed since it was listed?
  • What are the HOA dues, how often are they billed, and what do the CC&Rs allow (RV parking, fences, sheds)?
  • Is this a Signature or Luxury Series home, and can I get the features list for this exact home?
  • Can I use my own lender?
  • Can I see the one-year warranty agreement, and is there any structural warranty beyond it?

More guides for new-construction buyers

Prices, features, HOA fees and availability change often. Figures here come from crhidaho.com and public Snake River MLS listing pages checked October 26, 2026. Always verify current pricing and availability directly with Castlerock Homes at (208) 557-3786. Jacob Marcovitz is a REALTOR® with Keller Williams Realty East Idaho and is not employed by Castlerock Homes or any builder. Nothing here is legal advice.

Jacob Marcovitz, REALTOR®, Keller Williams Realty East Idaho, 3525 Merlin Dr, Idaho Falls, ID 83404. Call or text 208-821-6217, or connect with me here.

Categories

Home Builders in East Idaho
Agent profile image in chat bubble
Agent profile image in chat header

Jacob Marcovitz

| Jacob Marcovitz | Keller Williams Realty East Idaho

Agent profile image in message

or another way